You master the argument and know what technical evidence is worth to it. What many practices lack is the expert alongside them: the one who sustains the legal argument with proof.
When to engage the party-appointed expert, what to do at each stage, CPC deadlines and the digital evidence preservation checklist.
Download the guide Training22 courses in four tracks, 2 to 4 hours each, in person or live online, open class or in-house. Taught in Portuguese, under Brazilian law.
See the courses First conversationAn early technical conversation defines the right examination, what to preserve and what to ask the court for.
Write to the expertWhen a dispute is decided by technical evidence, the best legal argument is held hostage by the expert report. The court-appointed expert is impartial, but works under heavy caseload, with no duty to explore the points that favour your client. Without qualified technical challenge, the official report tends to pass as absolute truth.
A trusted party-appointed expert reverses that asymmetry: he drafts the questions to the expert that steer the forensic examination towards what your case needs, follows every act of the court-appointed expert, identifies flaws in method and in chain of custody, and produces the dissenting technical opinion that grounds challenges and appeals.
One mistake grows more frequent: hiring the party-appointed expert only to draft the questions. The professional delivers the questions, but has not studied the case nor analysed the evidence. The result, often enough, is a question that harms the client who asked for it.
Anyone can write questions, artificial intelligence included. Without the forensic analysis of the evidence, the chance of error is high, and the lawyer puts the case at risk by trusting someone who drafts without examining.
The work is joint: the party-appointed expert brings the elements, strengthens counsel's case and advises on the risks and the flaws of the technical process. Including the most delicate one: the evidence the client himself holds and that may work against him.
Counsel must receive that information before the court does, and decide clearly what should and should not go on the record.
A report can be technically correct and still be of no use to the case. That happens when the examination answers what interests the technician, and not what the case needs to prove.
Here, the technical reading starts from the argument and the strategy counsel is going to use. Before examining, the expert understands what needs to be demonstrated and at what stage the proceedings are. He identifies the rules of evidence that weigh on the material: chain of custody in criminal proceedings, the record retention periods of the Marco Civil da Internet (Brazil's internet framework), the duties under the LGPD (Brazil's data protection act) and the forensic procedure in the CPC (Brazilian Code of Civil Procedure). He then organises the examination to answer that and points out what still needs to be requested or preserved.
Digital law underlies almost every case that reaches the laboratory. It is that knowledge that makes the technical examination speak to the legal pleading. The argument remains counsel's.
Many cases reach the law firm with a technical question at the centre: a hacked account, unauthorised access, an electronic document, a data leak, a system that failed. Technical consulting in Digital Law is the support for counsel to conduct these cases safely, without the risk of losing the case through lack of technical knowledge.
The service is exclusive to lawyers and to the legal and compliance departments of companies. It is not offered to individuals. Nor is it legal advice, which is an activity reserved to the legal profession (Lei 8.906/1994, art. 1º, II, the Brazilian Bar statute). The expert delivers the technical facts and the path to prove them. The legal strategy and the pleading belong to counsel.
What the available evidence supports, what still needs preserving, which examination to request and which expert questions to formulate, before the statement of claim or the defence.
The technical grounds of the request: which data to ask for, from whom, with which identifiers, source port and time zone. The law firm applies that information in the pleading. Afterwards, the forensic examination cross-checks what the provider or the platform returns.
Learn moreThe Expert Report, or the Technical Report when urgency demands it, that brings to the police authority or to the public prosecutor the authorship and the materiality already demonstrated technically, and not just a police report.
The technical inquiry into the employee's conduct, commissioned by compliance or by labour counsel. The decision is the company's; the report gives it grounds not to be reversed.
It is in the stage before filing that technical assistance pays the most. The preliminary examination reviews every piece of evidence that will support the claim, maps strong and weak points and answers the question that prevents loss: is the claim worth filing? Not rarely, the analysis reveals evidence the client did not know he had, already fit for the evidentiary stage.
And there is the most powerful move: filing the statement of claim already accompanied by an expert report that demonstrates everything the pleading asserts. The court receives the technical piece from day one; by the time the forensic stage arrives, it is already on the record. There is no way to mislead the court-appointed expert: all that remains for him is to verify and confirm that the technical opinion filed tells the truth.

A page, a profile or a conversation may vanish before service of process. The notarial deed fixes the content with the public faith of the notary and may include image or sound data recorded in electronic files (CPC, art. 384). It is worth what it contains: what the notary did not record at that moment will hardly be recovered later.
Before the deed is drawn up, the expert gives counsel the list of what a deed of online content needs to carry to withstand a challenge. For example: the full address of the page or profile, the date and time with the time zone, the identifiers of the account and of the device, the path followed to reach the content and the hash of the saved files. The expert's review of the draft is delivered within 24 hours.
In on-site collection, such as the duplication of the disks of a computer under investigation, the deed becomes an audit of the technical procedure: see Method and Chain of Custody.
The deed reinforces the evidence, but does not replace the forensic examination. When the conversation or the file is the central piece of the case, forensic extraction remains the way.
When the party has been granted free legal aid, the court-appointed expert is paid from the court's own schedule or, failing that, from the schedule of the CNJ (National Council of Justice), set by CNJ Resolution 232/2016, which the judge may exceed with reasons given. For an examination that takes dozens of hours of technical work, the scheduled amount is a fraction of what the expert associations indicate as a market benchmark. The distance between the two is not a detail: it is an order of magnitude.
The consequence is arithmetic, not anyone's fault: even intending to do meticulous work, the professional appointed under those conditions has no way to devote to the case the dozens of hours a deep examination demands. The recurring result is simplified reports, in which the points that would favour your case are left unexplored.
And the risk falls precisely on the party who did not pay for the examination: if the simplified report concludes against her, even when she is right, the truth of the case becomes what is written in it. A challenge signed by counsel alone rarely turns that around, because in the eyes of the court the lawyer is, by definition, the interested party: his technical submission arrives filtered by the presumption of partiality, while the court-appointed expert speaks with the standing of an impartial officer of the court. The same technical argument counts for little in a lawyer's brief and counts for a great deal signed by a forensic expert.
It is this double asymmetry, of hours and of credibility, that the forensic expert acting as party-appointed expert corrects: retained by the party, with fees that match the work, he devotes to the case the hours the public schedule cannot cover and brings to the proceedings a voice with the same technical standing as the appointed expert's, in the questions, in the site visits and in the opinion that deepens what the report left shallow. In a dispute that matters, the question is not whether that dedication makes a difference; it is which side of the table will have it.
There are 15 days from service of the appointment order to name the forensic expert acting as party-appointed expert and to file the questions to the expert (CPC, art. 465, § 1 of the Brazilian Code of Civil Procedure), and the window does not reopen. Cases with a running deadline take priority: first reply within 12 hours, during business hours.
The best scenario for the examination. Bring the available evidence and the strategic goal: the preliminary examination guides the construction of the claim from the start.
Provide the full case file. It is the analysis of the proceedings, of what has already been produced and of what is still available, that defines the next technical steps.
When to engage the party-appointed expert, what to do at each stage, the forensic examination deadlines in the CPC (Brazilian Code of Civil Procedure) and the digital evidence preservation checklist. Download it and use it on the next case.
Following the work of the court-appointed expert, in defence of the client's technical interests.
Technical support at the pre-examination stage. Well built questions are the main quality factor of a court forensic examination.
Independent technical opinion, to instruct the claim or to support the decision on whether to litigate.
Critical analysis of the adverse report: method, chain of custody, reasoning and conclusions.
Technical inquiry into fraud, misappropriation and incidents, with evidence usable in court.
Ongoing technical guidance for legal teams dealing with digital evidence.
Technical support to counsel in cases with technology at the centre: authorship, disclosure orders, preservation, notarial deed and expert questions. Exclusive to lawyers and compliance departments.
The list of what a notarial deed of online content needs to record, the review of the draft within 24 hours and, in on-site collection, the notary's attendance as an audit of the technical procedure.
Testimony happens when the expert signs a report or an opinion in the case, as court-appointed expert or as the party-appointed expert. In civil proceedings, a party may ask that the expert or the party-appointed expert be summoned to attend the hearing, with the questions formulated as expert questions (CPC, art. 477, § 3º). In criminal proceedings, party-appointed experts may submit opinions or be examined at the hearing (CPP, art. 159, § 5º, II, Brazilian Code of Criminal Procedure).
Acting as the company's representative (preposto) is excluded, in every case. The representative speaks for the company. The expert speaks for the evidence, and it is that independence that gives weight to what he says at the hearing. Mixing the roles would weaken precisely what counsel needs at his side: a technical voice the court hears as technical.
Pricing per case, with a detailed technical proposal. Options: fixed fees or technical hourly rate. The initial viability consultation is free of charge.
Send the case for a viability review

Banking, labour, family and succession, LGPD, compliance, insurance, competition, corporate, litigation and arbitration, and others. The page Forensic Examination by Area of Law shows, area by area, the typical situations, the examinations and the questions counsel usually asks.
An early technical conversation defines the right examination, what to preserve and what to ask the court for. Describe the case in a few lines: the feasibility review is free of charge, with professional confidentiality from the first contact.
The time limit, counted from notice of the court expert's appointment, to appoint a party expert and submit questions (CPC, art. 465, § 1). Do not wait for it to engage one: the pre-litigation review and the preliminary opinion give the case its technical footing.
Some of these cases are reported in anonymised form, with confidentiality fully preserved. You may recognise yourself in one of them.